Agency leaders and advisers in the UK, New Zealand, Southeast Asia and Japan on how investment attraction is changing. Most of them agree that what a place helps investors build counts more today than what it announces.
In the interview that opened this series, FDI adviser Martin Phelan described investment promotion as a relationship business, not a marketing exercise. We wanted to know if people working in other markets see it the same way. So we asked agency leaders and independent advisers three questions: what separates the places that get their positioning right, what makes investors choose a place today, and which places are worth watching.
Our contributors look at the topic from very different positions. Joe Manning leads Invest Manchester. Robert Wall is building Invest New Zealand from scratch. Andrew Keable, an Asia-Pacific trade and investment expert, specialises in ASEAN and works with governments and companies across the region. Dominic Mason works with developers and places across Southeast Asia from Singapore. Shingo Inoue advises Japanese regions from Tokyo. Kristian Schnack, Martin’s colleague at DKMR Associates, has advised investment agencies across Africa. Still, their answers have a lot in common.
For Andrew Keable, the agencies that stand out today are those that “can show investors what happens after approval”. Incentives and campaigns are no longer enough. Investors want to know that a project can be built, supplied and scaled. He mentions Malaysia, where the investment authority MIDA reports that 84.9% of manufacturing projects approved between 2021 and 2025 have reached some stage of implementation. “The measure of success should be what a location helps investors build, not simply the value of announcements it generates.”
Shingo Inoue sees a similar change in Japan. Regions have moved away from competing on cheap land and tax breaks. They now present themselves as partners that help investors succeed after arrival, “by removing barriers rather than adding incentives”. In practice, this means one contact person with real authority across water authorities, environmental boards, ministries and local government, as well as introductions to local companies and universities.
Robert Wall describes Invest New Zealand’s ambition in similar terms. In a few years, he wants the agency to be seen as “the trusted source for global investors considering New Zealand”: commercially minded, well connected, and able to match investors with credible opportunities at scale.
Manchester is a good example of how this looks in a city’s pitch. Joe Manning describes “an approach to investment that prioritises both economic and social impact”, linked to specific growth locations: innovation districts such as Mayfield, Atom Valley across Bury, Rochdale and Oldham, and MIX Manchester next to the airport, supported by a £2 billion Good Growth Fund. So investors are shown concrete sites, not only sectors.
In very different markets, we therefore see a similar change. The offer is less about what an investor gets for coming, and more about the support they receive after arrival.
On place reputation
On reputation, the answers differ more. Robert Wall gives it a lot of weight: New Zealand is associated with trust, transparency, stability, good governance, environmental quality and innovation. But he also links these attributes to companies that use New Zealand’s advantages in energy, food security, free trade and new technologies.
Shingo Inoue is more cautious. “Reputation works as boardroom risk mitigation,” he says. It shapes expectations before an investor has direct experience of a place, helps to draw up a shortlist and gives reassurance, but it is rarely the deciding factor. And it only holds when there is proof behind it, such as anchor tenants, one-stop support and a track record.
For Andrew Keable, “reputation is built through delivery”. Existing investors are the most credible reference for new ones, and a company that comes back to expand is a stronger signal than another investment announcement. Martin Phelan made the same point in his interview, suggesting that at least half of an agency’s projects should come from investors already in place.
Joe Manning sees reputation playing a role mainly when it comes to talent. Once the business case works, he says, “the decision usually comes down to whether a company can recruit the people it needs and have a clear path for future growth”. This is where culture, sport and quality of life matter, and here Manchester has an advantage: “most people already know something about the city through its football, its music or its universities”. Puma moved its UK headquarters to Manchester partly for these reasons. And graduates stay: the city keeps more than half of them, the highest rate outside London.
Kristian Schnack goes one step further. “I am not sure general ‘reputation’ is as important as sector reputation,” he says. Investors want to know whether a place is strong in their industry, whether it is known for supporting it, and what other companies in the sector say about it. He also mentions softer factors: whether investors feel understood by the agency and welcomed by the place.
In TPBO’s view, this is not bad news for place branding. It shows how closely reputation and delivery are connected. Claims that can be checked, for example through named investors and published results, carry more weight than those that cannot.
How investment attraction is changing
Several contributors also see investment pitches becoming more specific. Shingo Inoue describes Japanese regions moving towards a clear sector identity: Hokkaido for green transformation, semiconductors and AI, Fukuoka for startups and fintech, Aichi for manufacturing combined with startups. Andrew Keable expects successful governments to identify two or three investment-ready projects in each ecosystem, and to bring land, utilities, approvals and compliance together through a single point of contact. And they need to “speak the language of investors”, meaning market access, risk, returns and speed rather than administrative processes.
For Kristian Schnack, much of this depends on the people working in an agency. “FDI promotion is classic B2B sales and marketing,” he says, and too many agencies are staffed by people without a business background. Agencies that understand what drives demand in an industry can position themselves much more precisely.
At the same time, governments are no longer the only ones making the case for a place. Dominic Mason sees developers in Vietnam shaping how places present themselves to investors, with large townships, precincts and mixed-use projects well beyond Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi. As the government asks property developers to deliver airports and stadiums, “these developers need to attract not just capital investment but operational expertise”. This raises the question of who is responsible for a place’s reputation when developers, special zones or cross-border partnerships present it to investors. We come back to this in our essay on Southeast Asia.
Places worth watching
Johor in southern Malaysia was mentioned by two contributors, Andrew Keable and Dominic Mason. Here the Johor-Singapore Special Economic Zone combines Singapore’s capital and connectivity with Johor’s land and industrial capacity. Dominic also suggests Penang, where Silicon Island, a 930-hectare reclaimed island, is being built. Andrew names Sarawak, whose renewable energy attracts energy-intensive investment such as data centres, and Cambodia, where he supported the national investment promotion strategy. He also points to the ASEAN Power Grid, which according to the International Energy Agency will need more than US$300 billion in grid investment between 2025 and 2040.
In Japan, Shingo Inoue sees three types of places: Kumamoto and Hokkaido, where national semiconductor policy drives investment; Fukuoka, a locally driven gateway for startups and fintech; and Fukushima, where the Innovation Coast Framework built new industries in robotics, energy and aerospace after 2011. He also finds Toyama interesting, as it is turning its quality of life into a more targeted economic strategy.
Robert Wall, as head of a new agency, looks to Singapore, South Korea and Denmark, which combine autonomy, political support, commercial skills, a focused set of sectors and a strong international presence. Dominic Mason, who is based in Singapore, adds that the city state has long been on the radar of international investors, and more recently also of family offices, with effects on the premium residential market and beyond. Kristian Schnack mentions agencies with strong private-sector boards, with Costa Rica, Ireland and Singapore as classic examples. In Africa, where he did most of his work, he names the Tanzania Investment and Special Economic Zones Authority, and the one-stop centre of KenInvest in Kenya, which has made permits much easier for investors.
Joe Manning’s list is “Austin, Barcelona and Cambridge“, all cities Manchester works with: Austin for attracting tech companies and managing fast growth, Barcelona for culture and creativity, and Cambridge for innovation and research.
How we read it
What does this mean for places? In our view, those that can show what investment has actually delivered, such as implementation rates, reinvestment by existing investors or named companies, will be more convincing. So far, few places publish this kind of information.
In the next parts of this series we look at what the main investment rankings measure, and at how Indian states and Southeast Asian countries present their results.
With thanks to Joe Manning (Managing Director, Invest Manchester), Robert Wall (Chief Executive, Invest New Zealand), Andrew Keable (Co-Founder and Managing Director, KW Group), Dominic Mason (Managing Director SEA, Sedgwick Richardson), Shingo Inoue (Branding Director, Makaira KK) and Kristian Schnack (DKMR Associates).
