With climate change, augmenting (water, air) pollution and upcoming resource constraints haunting those with an attention span longer than a working week, not surprisingly sustainability and the natural environment have become essential parts of city and country rankings nowadays.
PricewaterhouseCoopers’ “Cities of Opportunity” Report is no exception and yet another proof that, across ideological divides and political benches, sustainability has emerged as a key challenge and aspiration, with a strong impact on a place’s (or organization’s) global competitiveness in the long-term.
According to the PwC report, Sydney, Stockholm, Paris, Berlin, San Francisco and Toronto are among the cities that most stand out for environmental best practice and sustainability.
Sustainable cities = cities of opportunity
Overall, the report features 10 indicators, organized into three families that – according to PwC – reflect the fundamentals of a well-balanced city: forward-looking tools such as education and technology; quality of life making cities healthy, happy, and sustainable; and the ability to pay the bills for it all.
Sustainability, livability and quality of life
Four indicators are used to determine a city’s quality of life, with infrastructure (from mass transit and housing to hospitals to waste management and public parks) taking center stage in the report. “The development and maintenance of infrastructure contribute directly and enormously to a city’s quality of life.” European cities score highest for infrastructure, followed by North American cities.
The report puts Sydney first in livability – or quality of life, while London beckons to would-be expats (PwC staff) as place they would most like to work, followed by New York City (a survey among the 15,000 PwC employees was used as indicator).
Economic success raises citizen expectations
The following statement should be particularly relevant to Chinese city officials: “After a certain level of economic success, a city’s residents demand more from municipal administrations. In fact, economic success normally is seen as (and historically has been) the basis for those improvements in urban life that lead to a city’s infrastructural development, from schools, hospitals, and police to roads, buses, and metros to libraries, parks, and environmental sustainability.”
While it might be the simple demographic fact of population density and expansion that turns towns into cities, it is the self-consciousness of citizens—and their proud participation in the growth of their respective cities—that urges cities to improve the quality of life of the men and women who live in them.”
Sustainable city indicators
The following sustainability indicators were used for the sustainable city liveability ranking:
Natural disaster risk: risk of natural disasters occurring in or near a city. Counted hazards include hurricanes, droughts, earthquakes, floods, landslides and volcanic eruptions.
Thermal comfort: A thermal comfort score was created for each city by calculating the average deviation from optimal room temperature (72 degrees Fahrenheit). January, April, July and October heat indices were calculated for each city using an online tool that integrates average high temperature and corresponding relative evening humidity during each month. A final thermal comfort score was derived by first taking the difference between a city’s heat index for each month and optimal room temperature and then averaging the absolute values of these differences.
Recycled waste: Percentage of municipal solid waste diverted from landfill.
Air pollution: Combination of measures of PM10 outdoor air pollution levels from the World Health Organisation (WHO) and the Numbeo Pollution Index of overall pollution in each city. The World Health Organization’s Public Health and Environment database provides annual mean concentrations of particulate matter 10 micrometers (PM10) in diameters or less which reflect the degree to which urban populations are exposed to this fine matter. The Numbeo Pollution Index is generated via survey based data. Numbeo attribute the biggest weight to air pollution, then to water pollution/accessibility, as the two main pollution factors. A small weight is given to other pollution types.
Public park space: Proportion of a city’s land area designated as public recreational and green spaces to the total land area. Excludes undeveloped rugged terrain or wilderness that is either not easily accessible or not conducive to use as public open space.
Read more about the PwC Cities of Opportunity report
While acknowledging the importance of sustainability for city livability, the report falls short in offering any compelling insights, case studies or examples of environmental best practice or sustainability in these cities, the latter from the feel of it being regarded a mere lifestyle issue.
Nice touch acknowledging the importance of citizen opinion, though basing quality of life rankings on PwC expat opinions is hardly useful a parameter for anyone not belonging to the jet setting elite, whose expenses are often paid for by their masters.
Most figures used are based on official documents and statistics provided by the cities themselves.
Sydney, not surprisingly, is popular among expats for its beaches, weather, and work-life balance. But is this enough for #1 in livability worldwide? To their credit, the city of Sydney does have an ambitious sustainability vision and strategic plan, though if you ask Australian sustainability thinkers, shakers and doers like Ross Lardner from award-winning Sydney Harbour YHA, then what you’re likely to hear is that the Australian metropolis is still far from a green metropolis.
Overall, what are the environmental and sustainability challenges – and opportunities for world’s leading cities? Key questions the PwC’s “Cities of Opportunity” could have addressed more convincingly.
Enjoyed this post on the PwC Cities of Opportunity report? Share and spread the word!
Latest posts by The Editorial Team (see all)
- Smart Cities and City Branding: How ICT Impacts Urban Development and Representation - 18 October 2018
- City Nation Place Awards 2018: Finalists Announced - 16 October 2018
- Interview with Myriam Gómez of Marca Chile on Country Branding Strategies - 11 October 2018